Akhil Ilango

Ph.D. candidate in Economics

Universitat Pompeu Fabra, Barcelona


Primary field: Industrial Organisation

Currently working on: Digital Economy, Market Power, Lobbying, Misallocation

I'm on the 2022-23 Job Market.

You can access my CV and Research here.




You can reach me at: 


Responsive image
Sponsored Search

Job Market Paper

Draft

Fact 1:

Fact 2:

Question:

This paper:

Novel channel:

Implication:

Dominant digital platforms

Rising product market concentration

How do digital platforms affect product market competition?

Effects of Sponsored Ads

Pass-through of ad commission into product pricing is asymmetric across ad position
Higher pass-through to price of non-prominent firm: reduces its ability to compete using price

Ad auction reduces product market competition and consumer welfare


Framework

Step 1: Effect of prominence and price visibility, in absence of ad auction

Price visibility affects both search and purchase decision


Price visibility increases price elasticity



Step 2: Equilibrium with auction

Heterogenous pass-through of ad commission by position


Ad auction reduces ability of firm 2 to compete through prices


Reduced competition leads to lower consumer surplus

More results in the paper:
Extension: Vertically differentiated firms
Counterfactuals (to-do): Per-sale commission, Consumer subscription, Platform as a firm

Upcoming: Structural estimation of pass-through from ad commissions to product prices

CV

Education

 Ph.D. in Economics, UPF, Barcelona, 2023 (exp.)
 M.Res. in Economics, UPF, Barcelona, 2019
 M.Sc. in Economics, BSE & UPF, Barcelona, 2018
 B.Tech. in Mechanical Engg., NIT-T, India, 2017

Office

 C/ Ramon Trias Fargas 25-27
 08005 Barcelona
 Department of Economics and Business
 Universitat Pompeu Fabra

Working Papers

* Sponsored Search: Theory and Evidence on How Platforms Exacerbate Product Market Concentration Presentations: 2022 - JEI, EARIE, JapMES, CMID-NUS, AusMES, ICT-ZEW, AsMES, ISMS, DIW, Warwick PhD, MWET, TADC, AFES, Humboldt, SMYE, RES, 2021 - Delhi WS, UPF, Stockholm IO Workshop, BSE Jamboree

Abstract  Draft Appendix

 How do sponsored advertisements affect product market concentration, through their effects on firms' pricing and consumer behaviour? To analyse this, I develop a theory of digital markets where an intermediary provides a platform for firms to advertise their product and where consumers need to engage in costly search if they want to learn about the product characteristics. First, I show that when prices are observable prior to the costly product inspection, the less prominent (lower in the search order) firm is forced to lower its price in order to attract more visitors, thus putting it at a competitive disadvantage. Second, I augment this model by allowing the intermediary to determine endogenously, through an auction, the order in which products are displayed and the advertising commissions to be paid (per-click). I show that the pass-through from these commissions to product prices is actually higher for the less prominent firm, thus further putting it at a competitive disadvantage. In equilibrium, these asymmetries in consumer price elasticity and commission pass-through lead to lower competition, consumer surplus and total transactions in the product market. Third, I show that the pay per- click business model is intermediary-optimal while the pay per-sale and the consumer subscription fee models improve consumer surplus at the expense of the intermediary. Fourth, I provide novel empirical evidence that is consistent with some key predictions of the model. These results contribute to the ongoing policy discussions on the effect of dominant digital platforms on product market concentration.



* Sleeping With the Enemy: How Politicians and Interest Groups Adapt their Collaborations in the Face of Reputational Threats with Miguel Espinosa and Giorgio Zanarone Presentations (me & co-authors): 2022 - SIOE - U Toronto, Strategy Science - NYU, Indiana U, MIT Sloan, Bocconi

Abstract 

 How does the reputation of interest groups affect their collaboration with politicians? We address this question using unique data on the public speeches andlobbying contacts of U.S. legislators. We find that when external events tarnish a foreign country's reputation, legislators with prior connections to that country publicly distance themselves from it through their speeches, while meeting more often with its lobbyists. Our results suggest that politicians and interest groups navigate crises by strategically decoupling the public and private dimensions of their collaboration. On the one hand, politicians protect themselves from reputational spillovers through public distancing. On the other hand, interest groups increase the assistance they provide to politicians via lobbying in order to motivate those politicians to continue a private collaboration that is now less appealing to them.


Work In-Progress

* Demand Distortions, Markups and Firm Growth with Sampreet Goraya

Abstract 

 Local demand is an important determinant of firm growth in rural areas. In this project, we document the role of ethnic networks in segmenting the local demand and its implication for local firm growth and aggregate misallocation. We focus our analysis on India, where the caste system plays a significant role on individuals' economic outcomes. First, we show that demand is segmented along caste lines. This, in turn, creates markup and productivity dispersion across firms owned by different castes. To identify this demand segmentation effect, we use exogenous changes in regional rainfall intensity as an instrument for local demand shocks. We find that consumers historically classified as belonging to the Low Caste (LC consumers) experience a positive income shock due to rainfall and that this translates into higher per-capita consumption for them. Further, we show that regional increase in the LC consumers' demand translates into higher output growth and lower markup for the firms owned by members of the same caste-category, relative to others. Using a quantitative model, we plan to quantify the significance of demand channel in determining firm growth and misallocation.


* Sponsored Search: Evidence from Clickstream Data

* The Dynamics of Firm Prominence

Book Chapters

* Current Challenges for Competition in Online Advertising Markets with Rosa Ferrer and Paul Richter in Reforms to foster competition in Spain, edited by Juanjo Ganuza and Joaquín López Vallés, published by The Spanish National Markets and Competition Commission (CNMC)

Abstract (in Spanish)  Draft (in Spanish)

 Tanto en EE. UU. como en España, la publicidad online ya supuso en 2021 más del 50 por 100 del gasto total en publicidad. Unido a múltiples retos ya conocidos por los economistas (barreras de entrada por economías de escala, switching costs, efectos de red), la publicidad online añade además la personalización de la publicidad y las dificultades para preservar la privacidad. Veremos que la publicidad online potencialmente puede tanto favorecer como dificultar la competencia. Repasaremos literatura académica que ofrece claves para identificar y cuantificar formas en que la publicidad online puede generar barreras a la competencia y daños a los consumidores.


Collaborators

Espinosa, Miguel (U Bocconi)
Ferrer, Rosa (U Pompeu Fabra)
Goraya, Sampreet (Stockholm SE)
Richter, Paul (U Pompeu Fabra)
Zanarone, Giorgio (HEC Lausanne)

Teaching


TA - UPF Undergraduate

  • Industrial Organisation
  • Regulation and Competition Policy
  • Microeconomics 1
  • Microeconomics 2
  • Modern Statistical Computing in R
  • Data Analysis
  • Business Organisation and Management
  • Introduction to Macroeconomics
  • Mathematics for Finance